Originally posted by: The Boston StRiPeR on 8/14/2007 8:39:35 AM

i think there all good choice's but I voted of Saltwater fishing articles myself. Being a person thats very much into both depending on my mood.

Originally posted by: loki1331 on 8/8/2007 9:23:18 PM

I am taking a poll to see what other members would like to see in our magazine. Please choose one of the answers below.

Originally posted by: hillbillyangler on 8/15/2007 7:03:27 AM

I'd really Love to see some Carp Articals in the up and coming issues.

Originally posted by: ChrisG on 8/15/2007 7:45:27 AM

I voted "other".
I would like to see more fly fishing articles. Not just trout, either. Warm water species - bass, pike, carp...

Originally posted by: hillbillyangler on 8/15/2007 7:51:45 AM

quote:

Originally posted by ChrisG:
I voted "other".
I would like to see more fly fishing articles. Not just trout, either. Warm water species - bass, pike, carp...

Originally posted by: Bass Fishing Rules! on 8/15/2007 8:53:00 AM

I voted for lures tips & tips, because in my 9 years of fishin I still dont know the good fish catchin techs.

Originally posted by: ChrisG on 8/15/2007 9:47:05 AM

quote:

Originally posted by hillbillyangler:
Chris I have read articals and post on other forums about catching carp on a fly rod , man i bet that would be fun. I fish with medium rods when fishing for them and man its a blast on lite tackle. have you ever caught a carp on your fly rod?

Originally posted by: hillbillyangler on 8/15/2007 12:48:17 PM

yes I have , and I also Saw cag ( carp anglers group ) and Was the West Virginia State Chairmen 2006-2007 then I resigned due to personial Reasons. me and a fellow NAFC Lifer , Got together and started our own message forum also , Not as compatition nor to make money , just to help promote , hunting , fishing and the out doors. http://www.justplainfishin.net

I really enjoy catching carp as well as catfish and other spieces , as a matter of fact , I'd give all fishing up if I could Just pan fish the rest of my life <!--graemlin:;)-->

Originally posted by: panfish headcase on 8/15/2007 5:53:38 PM

I would have to say fly fishing, I was taught to fly fish by my dad as a small one and love todo it. I like to fish big bull bluegill on a fly rod man you talk about fun.

Life member
adams@vci.net

Originally posted by: BillTell on 8/17/2007 6:11:28 PM

I voted "other", because they were basically all good choices, and I'd rather see more concise information rather than reading about some "fine tuning" information I will never use. I just don't get on the water often enough,(do any of us?lol) so I want to maximize my potential the time I am there. I love the "tips" section. Just one small picture with 3 sentences can be so much more informative than a whole article on fishing a situation I'll never encounter, such as how to find fish that bite in a freezing rain in October. Know whut Ah mean, Vern?

Originally posted by: ChrisG on 8/17/2007 6:41:09 PM

quote:

Originally posted by BillTell:
I just don't get on the water often enough,(do any of us?lol) so I want to maximize my potential the time I am there. I love the "tips" section. Just one small picture with 3 sentences

Originally posted by: flymaster5 on 8/19/2007 4:59:37 AM

I would like to see more salt water fishing
info comming from New England. And any other fishing tips fresh or salt from my area

Originally posted by: papa_d on 8/19/2007 5:11:38 AM

Less advertising and more fishing facts/stories...Papa_d

Originally posted by: hillbillyangler on 8/19/2007 2:10:52 PM

quote:

Originally posted by papa_d:
Less advertising and more fishing facts/stories...Papa_d

Originally posted by: papa_d on 8/19/2007 3:40:33 PM

I agree with the monthly mag...it used to be when I first started getting it. Also; how about a fishing stories from "The Good Old Day's"???

Originally posted by: hillbillyangler on 8/19/2007 7:35:34 PM

quote:

Originally posted by papa_d:
I agree with the monthly mag...it used to be when I first started getting it. Also; how about a fishing stories from "The Good Old Day's"???

Originally posted by: woo2 on 8/20/2007 12:04:34 PM

Here here, Get rid of the sex ads, tobacco ads, and ins ads. Put in more fishing related stuff. This is a fishing club, after all. If you need advertising dollars then put in the big companies ads , like rapala, Heddon, Bomber, etc. . And stop endorsing the junk like the kick tail lure. Give us some credit for having some smarts.

tom

Originally posted by: hillbillyangler on 8/20/2007 1:32:22 PM

quote:

Originally posted by woo2:
Here here, Get rid of the sex ads, tobacco ads, and ins ads. Put in more fishing related stuff. This is a fishing club, after all. If you need advertising dollars then put in the big companies ads , like rapala, Heddon, Bomber, etc. . And stop endorsing the junk like the kick tail lure. Give us some credit for having some smarts.

tom

Originally posted by: panfish headcase on 8/20/2007 3:05:17 PM

My hats off to you all, it would be nice to get the mag on a monthly time fram and not see all the junk ads. My 4 year old was looking at the mag with me one day and saw an ad for some snuff and said thats what we need to be able to fish. I had to explain that we did not need it.

Originally posted by: Mike Aaron (Toad) on 8/24/2007 3:31:40 AM

Well heres my 2 cents...
I would like to see the mag. Do some interviews with Members about the fishing in their area. For instance, I live in PA. I fish a wide variety of waters, from Kinzua (the zoo), Lake Erie, Vairous Smaller lakes and rivers. I don't want to hear from the Pro's, I would rather hear tips and tricks from members. Who I feel would be a lot more honest and give poeple some good advice. if anyone has a question about the waters in PA drop me a line.
As far as the Ads go. I agree with there are way to many. I'd like to see them put them all on the same pages, and keep them seperated. As for the Smokes and Snuff... I smoke and Chew already, but would rather our young people are not made think it's "cool" or OK...


Just my 2 Cents

Originally posted by: mr bill on 8/25/2007 12:06:26 PM

quote:

Originally posted by papa_d:
I agree with the monthly mag...it used to be when I first started getting it. Also; how about a fishing stories from "The Good Old Day's"???

Originally posted by: mr bill on 8/27/2007 7:01:39 AM

i just wanted to say i posted what i posted for everyone have an idea on how nafc mag. was like in it's infency and the changes that have happened over the years with other mags. also, not to kill the thread. <!--graemlin::(-->

changes happen because eithere we demand it or the ads. people do. the companys that run these mags. now days don't care about what we want, they only think of the bottom dollar. so if you want to see things happen in the mag. you must hit them hard, the question is though is were.

typing these last 2 post has made me think about a couple of things. so i am going to start a new post to ask a couple of questions and i hope it might shed some light on all our questions.



life member nahc, nafc, nra/ila
life scriber in-fisherman mag.
rapala field tesster
member of Eaton Rapids Sportsman Club

Originally posted by: hillbillyangler on 8/27/2007 12:51:35 PM

nice post man , makes ya think. I like the mag , But I agree , to many adds , and junk. I wanna read about what yall are doin , catchin , and so forth. Not what some pro fella is doin or what there doin on the kentucky river , shoot I thought thats why each state has a DNR web site for? LOL If I wanted Viagra , I see my doctor not read my fishin clubs magazine. LOL I tell ya to be honest , When i get the mag each month ( Or so ) I go directly to the members stuff , Pics , letters and reports , I skip 3/4's of the junk , and I try to tear out the add's and stuff but as of late its really hard do to them being on every page. Look I know it takes money and so forth to run a club , But I can't remember when i saw Steve Pennaz out of a job <!--graemlin:;)-->

Originally posted by: mr bill on 8/28/2007 3:21:32 PM

i woud like to see some of the old articals [styll that is] like have the pros right some of these articals. i bet most off them wouldn't know where to start.

i don't mind to hear were the best chance to get a state record or maybe a world record. but what are the chances of any one of us getting a state record let alone a world record.

in my 50 yrs. of fishing i have come close or did catch a record, but i really didn't/don't care. the one record i do now i could of had even if it would have been for a month or so. i caught a king salmon in late july the very first year the state of michigan had a mature salmon run in our rivers. this fish was 52 lbs, i was only 14 at the time. fishing the little manistee river for browns on a weekend canoe trip with my boyscout troop.

my last really nice size fish i caught was just two yrs. ago. i caught an 18lb. northern pike.

as i said before, i just want some of you to think about what we have missed and were we are haeded. go ahead and speak your mind. i do fell sorry for the younger kids because they have no idea what has already been missed and also what we have had to go through to get were we are today. the good and the bad.



life member nahc, nafc, nra/ila
life scriber in-fisherman mag.
rapala field tester
member of Eaton Rapids Sportsman Club

Originally posted by: mr bill on 8/29/2007 10:44:14 AM

in the other post i made a challenge to the youngsters and to us old geezers to learn or teachthings of the old and the new. lately i have been able to set back and read a lot of posts. i have found that every where on the board we find our little nich and post, ask questions respond to questions asked. i hear alot of the same questions asked over again and again just asked in a different form. i have seen articals in the mag. do the samething. take something that has been used in the late 50's or 60's, rewrite it and call it something new.
a good exsample is dropshoting, i was tought this methiod by an old freind when i was only about 8 yrs. of age, he was in his late 60's. i've seen many more articals like this.

as i said before i am just wanting to have everyone think about what has been fought for so we can enjoy our favorite sports.

mr bill



life member nahc, nafc, nra/ila
life scriber in-fisherman mag.
rapala field tester
member of Eaton Rapids Sportsman Club

Originally posted by: flymaster5 on 8/29/2007 1:55:33 PM

me bill
I must applaued your honesty listening (reading)to you is like I am hearing my passed away uncle
telling me to fish and when what to do how to do it. I was a member about 15 years ago but go very disapointed with all the adds and gimics
in the mag most of them had nothing to do with where I fish and what kind of fishing I do.
So I cancled my supscription I thought I would give it a try again this year and I see not much has changed except there is more adds and gimmices now than ever. I bearly even look at the mag when it comes my son who is now 17 reads it more than I do. He has been fishing since he was 5 and I constly tell him that not all you read is true he want to try this and try that because the pros say so.
I was taught to fish by my father salt water
mostly and fly and fresh water by my uncle.Both men I have a great respect for. I myself have been fishing for almost 40 years and I do miss the the stories and tips from the old days you can't be experince. So I say to all the young people who starting to fish listen to people like MR. BILL pick there brain there is lots of knowelge in there.
Thanks again mr bill for bringing it back to me.

A quick note my biggest fish I evere caugh was a 97 inch 104 pound Carbian sail fish which I caught In Cancun in 2006.
It now hangs in my den.

Originally posted by: mr bill on 9/6/2007 3:23:38 PM

there is a lot of different things i would like to post here, but i feel like i am just barking at the moon.

i do want to thank those that have posted that they had to stop and think about somethings going on in this world.

a question about those that are life members. are you putting the money that would have cost them for an annual script into something that is helping to perserve our hertiage or not. something like wildlife for ever, or something like that. name a few you think would be good to donate to.



life member nahc, nafc, nra/ila
life scriber in-fisherman amg.
rapala field tester
member of Eaton Rapids Sportsman Club

Originally posted by: flymaster5 on 9/10/2007 5:56:42 AM

I would love to see some more articles on fishing in New England fresh and salt water.

Anybody from the middle part of the country
know what it is like to hookinto a 40 inch plus
srtipper with only 16 pound test.
Thats fighting a fish.

Originally posted by: mr bill on 9/19/2007 10:23:40 AM

don't know if it will happen here. but if you can have a look at the hunting clubs web site. you are not going to like it if you are complaining about this web site. i wonder what the new mag is going to be like.

if you look and don't like read what i posted earlyer in this post and think.

mr bill



life member nahc, nafc, nra/ila
life scriber in-fisherman mag.
rapala field tester
member of Eaton Rapids Conservation Club

Originally posted by: Karl/PA on 9/19/2007 8:37:00 PM

I would love to see an apology for all the grief the advertisers here are creating with their spam advertising.

Originally posted by: Clay Derochie on 9/20/2007 9:05:17 AM

Hi There,

I'm new here and thought I'd get my feet wet.

I would like to see some articles on how to get started in some of the areas of fishing I would like to explore. For example, what are the first steps a guy or gal should take that is interested in fly fishing.

Clay

Originally posted by: mr bill on 9/21/2007 6:08:10 AM

hi clay, first like to welcome you to the fishing bb

second go to the fly fishing forum and you will get a lot of info. myself i could tell you the basics, but thear are guys there that are half my ago and 10 times better at explaining how to then i could.

good luck and hope to see ya more on the board <!--graemlin::cool:-->



life member nahc, nafc, nra/ila
life scriber in-fisherman mag.
rapala field tester
member of Eaton Rapids Conservation

Originally posted by: phantomtoo on 9/21/2007 5:58:13 PM

I would like to see the section below this one up-dated.

It's been December/January 2006-07 for almost a year!

Originally posted by: bayliner on 9/22/2007 1:37:35 PM

I would like to see a few articles about fly fishing and some about fishing in New Mexico.

Originally posted by: mr bill on 9/23/2007 6:52:14 PM

i hear ya frank.



life member nahc, nafc, nra/ila
life scriber in-fisherman mag.
rapala field tester
member of Eaton Rapids Conservation Club

Originally posted by: bayliner on 9/24/2007 5:53:56 AM

I like the idea of Warm water species - bass, pike, carp also. Excellent idea.....

Originally posted by: greenlantern on 9/24/2007 3:05:27 PM

quote:

Originally posted by flymaster5:
me bill
I must applaued your honesty listening (reading)to you is like I am hearing my passed away uncle
telling me to fish and when what to do how to do it. I was a member about 15 years ago but go very disapointed with all the adds and gimics
in the mag most of them had nothing to do with where I fish and what kind of fishing I do.
So I cancled my supscription I thought I would give it a try again this year and I see not much has changed except there is more adds and gimmices now than ever. I bearly even look at the mag when it comes my son who is now 17 reads it more than I do. He has been fishing since he was 5 and I constly tell him that not all you read is true he want to try this and try that because the pros say so.
I was taught to fish by my father salt water
mostly and fly and fresh water by my uncle.Both men I have a great respect for. I myself have been fishing for almost 40 years and I do miss the the stories and tips from the old days you can't be experince. So I say to all the young people who starting to fish listen to people like MR. BILL pick there brain there is lots of knowelge in there.
Thanks again mr bill for bringing it back to me.

A quick note my biggest fish I evere caugh was a 97 inch 104 pound Carbian sail fish which I caught In Cancun in 2006.
It now hangs in my den.

Originally posted by: flymaster5 on 9/25/2007 12:51:22 PM

Thanks GL for the response. That is how I got my son hooked on fishing cacthing a bunch of sunfish with worms.
I too am a mono man but my reels are better
and I still have a glass rod that I use some times. The pros make their living at fishing
I fish because I enjoy it and find it relaxing
maybe the mag can get back to the more peaceful
times of fishing.
Jack

Originally posted by: mr bill on 9/25/2007 5:23:11 PM

i'll applude that.



life member nahc, nafc, nra/ila
life scriber in-fisherman mag.
rapala field tester
member of Eaton Rapids Conservation Club

Originally posted by: WalleyeWayne on 9/25/2007 6:30:45 PM

I haven't received an NAFC mag in many moons <!--graemlin::eek:-->. Do they still publish one <!--graemlin::confused:-->.

Originally posted by: wellsley on 9/25/2007 6:48:11 PM

maybe there out fishing Wayne. <!--graemlin::D-->

Originally posted by: PiscMonkey on 9/25/2007 7:04:26 PM

I too would want to see fishing related articles, stories, making lures, hard and softbaits. flyfishing how to's, repairing & building rods & more. <!--graemlin::)-->

Originally posted by: greenlantern on 9/27/2007 12:39:08 PM

quote:

Originally posted by ChrisG:

quote:

Originally posted by hillbillyangler:
Chris I have read articals and post on other forums about catching carp on a fly rod , man i bet that would be fun. I fish with medium rods when fishing for them and man its a blast on lite tackle. have you ever caught a carp on your fly rod?

Not as of yet. I just got done building a St. Croix Avid 9' 6wt that I plan on using for bass and maybe an occasional carp.
I'm new to fly fishing, so it should be interesting to say the least <!--graemlin::D--> <!--graemlin::cool:-->

BTW: HBA, have you seen this site?:
Carp America

Originally posted by: Cricket on 9/27/2007 7:28:55 PM

The word "beginner" says it all, I voted for Tips and Tricks with Lures.
Maybe I can get some use out of my new lure collection <!--graemlin::)-->

-Cricket

Originally posted by: mr bill on 9/28/2007 4:44:49 AM

aahhhhh grasshopper, i mean cricket, welcome to fishing clubs bb.. we all are beginners to something at one time or another.

let us know what you like to do and what you would like to try. we have a lot of young people here that are wanting to know things and we have people here that can help with any questions you might have.

you might find us acting crazy every now and then [some more than others] but we are here to have fun and to see what we can do to either learn or help each other out.



life member nahc, nafc, nra/ila
life scriber in-fisherman mag.
rapala field tester
member of Eaton Rapids Conservation Club

Originally posted by: flymaster5 on 9/28/2007 1:35:56 PM

quote:

Originally posted by Cricket:
The word "beginner" says it all, I voted for Tips and Tricks with Lures.
Maybe I can get some use out of my new lure collection <!--graemlin::)-->

-Cricket

Originally posted by: Cricket on 9/28/2007 4:36:07 PM

Greetings to you both, pleasure to meet you.

There's nothing wrong with being crazy sometimes, I've been known for that a time or two. <!--graemlin::)-->

Unfortunately, this year I have not been fishing all too often. The dreaded word work, drowns some free time. I was in Spirit lake, IA in the beginning of this month, I figured no better time to learn then to buy a bunch of things I've never used and make them work. So on my way back to Illinois, I ended up in Berkley's fishing store (since I couldn't tour the "Pure fishing" factory across the street <!--graemlin::D-->), picked up some beetle spins, jig head hooks, small bladedancers, a shallow frenzy diver, a few poppers, and plastic worm bait.

This will add to my little collection of plastic lures, bobbers, steel leaders, swivels and the handy pliers and pocket knife in my tackle box.

I can't really say what I like to fish for, right now its more like anything I can catch. In the last year or two I have caught my share of small pan fish, bluegill, perch, catfish...oh catfish...thats my most popular catch with a leech.

hrm....now well.. besides my life story, I can be chatty on a subject I like.

-Cricket

Originally posted by: Mike Flake on 9/30/2007 1:16:47 PM

I whould like to get one..Been awhile

Originally posted by: ChrisG on 9/30/2007 5:43:55 PM

quote:

Originally posted by PiscMonkey:
repairing & building rods <!--graemlin::)-->

Originally posted by: wkry on 10/3/2007 10:45:30 AM

i'd really would liketo see more fly fishingin the mag

Originally posted by: wayne horn on 10/8/2007 12:04:30 PM

give away Ihave magazines from 1995 to 1999 if anyone is interested they can E-mail at homestead@grics.net.

Originally posted by: lendog6963 on 10/8/2007 6:19:26 PM

i would like to see more pages, that last issue was sorta thin <!--graemlin::cool:-->

Originally posted by: BigDog68 on 10/22/2007 6:44:35 PM

I want to see another page in the members section dedicated to the bulletin board stuff and all of the different events that members around the country are putting on that promotes the club. Anytime we put together a "Fishing Meet", we give them free advertising and promotion. So, for all we do, we would like a page that covers members meets and our local fishing reports, tips and more.... <!--graemlin::cool:-->

Originally posted by: sugarcreek angler on 10/23/2007 10:43:45 AM

quote:

Originally posted by wayne horn:
give away Ihave magazines from 1995 to 1999 if anyone is interested they can E-mail at homestead@grics.net.

Originally posted by: bayliner on 10/29/2007 8:35:52 AM

More pages. You realise I just looked at one of my magazines from a year ago and it had 100 pages?? What happened??????