Has anyone had sucess with catfish charlie dipbaits and doughbaits?  I went through a container of the shad scent with no results but its most likely the time of day I was fishing, I just got the blood and pole cracker.

i have caught a few on the shad but have had the best luck with the blood, usually catch at least one with it every time.

Thanks.

I have used the shad with good success, need to get more! Finally got out Sunday afternoon and caught 7 channel cats on Sonnys super sticky original stink bait with the biggest close to 4 lbs!