Mirror Carp
Last Post 15 Oct 2010 07:48 PM by fisherfanatic. 5 Replies.
Author Messages
skewlUser is Offline Veteran Poster Veteran Poster Send Private Message Posts:1009 skewl
--
02 Oct 2010 11:23 AM
    Was watching a TV program the other day and one of the species pursued was the mirror carp. Apprently it's just a common carp but it only had scales on the upper portion of its body, which is less of a species and more of a genetic mutation. Has anyone caught a mirror carp before? They're said to live in southern MA and northern RI, but because its a genetic mutation I assume they could be found anywhere.
    fisherfanaticUser is Offline Veteran Poster Veteran Poster Send Private Message Posts:1494 fisherfanatic
    --
    02 Oct 2010 10:15 PM

    All that genetic mutation began in quite a while ago in Asia, when some monks were messing with the Wild Carp's gene pool.  They actually came up with a mutation that makes the carp scaleless (easier to prepare for consumption)!   I believe they're called Leather Carp.  All of these carp mutations are found the U.S.  They are quite a bit rarer than regular Common Carp, though.  I, personally, have only caught Common Carp.  Common Carp are the result of the monks breeding the largest specimens of Wild Carp, so that down through the generations the fish would gradually become larger (for human consumption purposes).  The original Wild Carp was relatively small and only grew to about 10 pounds.  Today, we can catch fish 3 to 4 times that large.   When Common Carp were released into Wild Carp populations in Asia, they genetically destroyed the Wild Carp's original genetic code.  This in turn decimated the "true" Wild Carp.  

    "I may be physically at my computer right now, but my mind has gone fishing!" --Avid angler from MI and member since 2009--
    skewlUser is Offline Veteran Poster Veteran Poster Send Private Message Posts:1009 skewl
    --
    03 Oct 2010 08:10 AM
    Wow, that's very interesting. I guess it's a bit ironic now that we use catch and release.
    fisherfanaticUser is Offline Veteran Poster Veteran Poster Send Private Message Posts:1494 fisherfanatic
    --
    04 Oct 2010 02:36 PM
    Koi Carp are also genetically the same species as the Common Carp.  They are just the most colorful fish bred together to eventually have offspring that is orange, red, yellow, etc.
    "I may be physically at my computer right now, but my mind has gone fishing!" --Avid angler from MI and member since 2009--
    aeddvmUser is Offline New Poster New Poster Send Private Message Posts:24 aeddvm
    --
    12 Oct 2010 06:12 PM
    I catch mirror carp on occasion ( 2-3 a year) fishing the bottom at Spruce Run Reservoir in NJ. Easy to clean, which I appreciate and quite tasty. They fight just like a common carp and I get them mostly in early summer.
    fisherfanaticUser is Offline Veteran Poster Veteran Poster Send Private Message Posts:1494 fisherfanatic
    --
    15 Oct 2010 07:48 PM
    I'm not sure what carp taste like.  People in Asia have been consuming them for hundreds of years, so they must be pretty good.  You just have to make sure that they are caught from a clean (non-polluted) body of water (since they're bottom feeders).
    "I may be physically at my computer right now, but my mind has gone fishing!" --Avid angler from MI and member since 2009--


    ---