how long are you going to be in indy?
On the west side there is Eagle creek. Decent bank fishing, It has a 10hp limit.
Giest is on the NE side NO bank fishing, Million $$ homes surrounding it.
To the north is Morse Res, been there years ago only fished from a boat.
Monroe is about 1.5 hours south west in Bloomington.
Brookville is about 1.5 hours east and is a US Army Corps of Engineers lake. Total access. It has Trout stocked below the dam. I do not know when "trout season" is though.
Hope this of help
tom in indy EYE need a Clue